Fresh New Look, Fresh New Flavors

Now Serving Fresh, Made-to-Order Pizza!

Next time you’re at Eastview Mall, relax and refuel in the fresh new ambiance of Colie’s Café and Eatery. Our updated menu offers a bold and satisfying selection that’s sure to keep even the most dedicated shoppers going.

Order Online!

Need a meal to go? Say hello to the new Colie’s Café and Eatery online ordering system. Place your order, pick it up, or have it delivered. No hassle required.

Order Now


Bring Colie’s to your next gathering, or let us bring it to you.

How to order?

By email: • By phone: (585) 223-7280


Place your order 24 hours prior to your convenient time to be delivered or to pick-up.

Minimum order $75.00

Delivery fee $10.00 for 1 to 10 mile radius. • No fees for deliveries for 1 mile radius. • Pickup: No minimum order.

Deliveries and pick-up will come complete with napkins, utensils or trays. Our meals are prepared on demand with only the freshest quality of ingredients and to guarantee an excellent degustation.


Option 1: Serves 6—8 $59

  • 12-piece sandwich, wrap or combo tray.
  • Chips and homemade salsa OR 2 pounds of our homemade deli salads.

Option 2: Serves 15—18 $135

  • 24-piece sandwich, wrap or combo tray.
  • Tortilla chips and homemade salsa.
  • 4 pounds of our homemade deli salads.
  • 20 Mini cookie tray.

Option 3: Serves 25—30 $288

  • 36-piece sandwich, wrap or combo tray.
  • Tortilla chips and homemade salsa.
  • 6 pounds of our homemade deli salads.
  • 2 small house, Caesar or Greek salad.
  • 30 bottled water.
  • 40 mini cookie tray.


White, wheat (vegan) and marble rye (vegan) bread available.
$9.90 per item includes chips & salsa OR deli salad side.
Gluten-free options upon request.

Sandwiches $9.90

Apple Tuna Salad $9.90

Apple Tuna Salad with provolone, mayo, lettuce and tomato.

Waldorf Chicken Salad $9.90

Waldorf Chicken Salad with bacon, almonds, sliced cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato.

Turkey $9.90

Applewood bacon, mayo, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato.

Vegetarian $9.90

Homemade garlic hummus, boursin cheese, spinach, sliced tomatoes, red onions, sliced avocado, and cucumbers.

Chicken Caprese $9.90

Grilled chicken, sliced fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, balsamic vinaigrette, lettuce and tomato.

Roast Beef $9.90

Shaved roast beef, cheddar cheese, lettuce, red onion, tomato, horseradish mayo.

Condiments served on the side for all sandwiches.

Wraps $9.90

Chicken Caesar $9.90

Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons and Caesar dressing.

Veggie $9.90

Romaine, spinach, carrots, tomatoes, cucumbers, avocados, cheddar cheese, green peppers and our homemade garlic hummus.

Buffalo Chicken $9.90

Romaine, blackened chicken, tomatoes, celery, red onion, mozzarella and crumbly blue cheese with boom dressing.

West Coast $9.90

Romaine, grilled chicken, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, avocado and honey mustard dressing.

Turkey Avocado $9.90

Chopped bacon, swiss cheese, romaine lettuce, tomatoes and ranch dressing.

Sesame Ginger $9.90

Romaine, carrots, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken, chow mein noodles and sesame ginger dressing.


Small: $12 (serves 6-8) • Large: $24 (serves 12-18)


Romaine, spring mix, carrots, tomatoes, cucumbers, chickpeas, croutons.


Romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons.


Romaine, spring mix, roasted red peppers, red onions, black olives, feta cheese, banana peppers, cucumbers. Served with toasted naan wedges.

Deli Salads

Fresh homemade macaroni salad, pasta salad, tomato, cucumber, mozzarella salad.

Add-ons to salad:

Tuna, chicken salad, or grilled chicken

$20 / Small $32 / Large

Fruit Salad Bowl

$12 / Small $24 / Large


Small serves 6-8 • Large serves 12-18

Tortilla chips and homemade salsa $8.50 / Small

Tortilla chips and our homemade salsa.

Tortilla chips and homemade salsa $15 / Large

Tortilla chips and our homemade salsa.

Bagged kettle chips $1.80 / bag

Multiple flavors available.

Pepperoni, crackers and cheese tray $12 / Small

Pepperoni, crackers, pepper jack, swiss and cheddar cheese tray.

Veggie tray $12 / Small

Carrots, celery, green peppers, cucumbers, cherry tomatoes. Served with ranch and homemade garlic hummus.

Mini cookie tray, Small $16

Mini cookie tray, Large $32

Large cookie tray $2 / cookie


Fresh Brewed Coffee $12

Serves 8.

Fresh Brewed Unsweetened Tea $5 / gallon

2 Liter Soda $3 / each

Bottled Tea $3.50 / each

Ask about our current flavors.

Bottled Water $1.50 / each

Seltzer and Vitamin Water $2.50 / each

Hubert’s Lemonade $3.50 / each

Ask about our current flavors.


Open Daily

Monday – Saturday: 10am – 9pm
Sunday: 11am – 6pm

Colie’s Cafe and Eatery
658 Eastview Mall
Victor, NY 14564

Get in Touch

Phone: (585) 223-7280

Fax: (585) 223-7282



Follow us for updates:

Sign Up for Rewards

    Enjoy 10% off your meal when you eat at Colie’s (students, Eastview Mall employees & military personnel *must have ID present)
    Buy 10 entrees, get 11th free
    Cater with us 10 times and receive a $25 discount on the next order.

Stay Current

Subscribe to our newsletter for daily deals!

Close menu